How to get comment karma on Reddit on a new account, step by step

You get comment karma on Reddit by leaving short, useful comments early in threads that are still growing, in big subreddits that let new accounts comment, a few times a day, for weeks. There is no faster honest route. The rest of this is the order to do it in, and what goes wrong at each step.

What Reddit says below comes from its Help Center articles as we quoted them in our own guide to comment karma, read on November 10, 2026. Reddit can change its pages, so where this and Reddit disagree, Reddit is right.

What is comment karma, and where do I see mine?

Comment karma is the part of your karma that comes from votes on your comments. Reddit's article "What is karma?" calls karma a reflection of the upvotes and downvotes on your posts and comments, and says upvotes and karma don't have a one to one relationship, so a comment with a lot of upvotes won't always add the same amount of karma. To see yours, open your profile in the Reddit app and tap About. Post karma and comment karma are listed apart.

What goes wrong here: people count upvotes and expect the total to match. It won't, and Reddit doesn't publish the formula, so don't try to reverse it. Watch the number go up over a week, not after each comment.

Step 1: Is my account ready to comment at all?

Check that your email is verified before you start. Reddit says a verified email is one sign that you use Reddit in good faith, and some communities require it. It takes a minute and removes one reason a comment can fail.

Then look at your account age. Reddit's article on Post Check says a community can hold back people for account age, karma, or an unverified email, and the thresholds aren't published. So a brand new account will be turned away in some places, and nothing you do speeds up the calendar.

What goes wrong: a new account comments in a few strict communities, sees nothing appear, and decides karma is impossible. Those communities may simply be holding it back. Start where new accounts are let in, and come back to the strict places later.

Step 2: Where should I comment first?

Comment first in big, general subreddits and in the big ones for something you know well, such as cooking, games, cars or your city. More readers means more people who can upvote you. Before you comment anywhere, read the subreddit rules in the sidebar, since a removed comment earns nothing.

What goes wrong: picking small niche communities because they feel friendlier. A great comment in a thread few people read earns very little. Use the small places for the conversations you care about, and the big ones to build the number.

Reddit's Crowd Control setting, as its Help Center describes it, lets moderators collapse comments from new accounts or hold them for review. If your comments in one subreddit keep getting collapsed, that community may be using Crowd Control. Move on rather than fight it.

Step 3: Which threads are worth a comment?

Pick threads that are young and already moving. Sort a subreddit by Rising, or by New and choose posts under an hour old that already have a few comments. An early comment gets read by everyone who opens the thread later. A comment added after hundreds of others sits where few people scroll.

In a thread that is already big, reply under the first or second top comment instead of adding a new one at the bottom. A good reply there is read by far more people than a new comment would be.

What goes wrong: commenting on whatever is at the top of the front page. By the time most people see those threads they already have hundreds of comments, so a new one is rarely read.

Step 4: What should the comment say?

Say one useful or funny thing, in the tone the thread already has, in a line or two. Answer the question that was asked, with a detail the person can use. If the room is joking, joke. If someone asked a practical question, give the practical answer with the number or the step they need.

Comments that sink are the ones that add nothing: "This!", "so true", a long essay under a joke, or correcting someone who didn't ask. If you have nothing to add to a thread, skip it and open the next one. Fewer comments that people want to read earn more than many that they scroll past.

What goes wrong: writing for karma instead of for the person who asked. Karma reflects downvotes as well as upvotes, so a comment people dislike can take karma away.

Step 5: How many comments a day, and when?

Leave three to five comments a day, each in a different thread, spread through the day. Later on, answer anyone who replied to you. Those replies earn karma too.

Reddit has a filter for many comments in a few minutes. Its Help Center says a new account with little karma that does this gets "You're doing that too much" and has to wait. Spacing comments out avoids it. If you want to time them, our free tool for the best time to post shows which days and hours a subreddit's most upvoted recent posts went up.

What goes wrong: a burst of comments in one sitting. It trips the rate limit, and comments written that fast are usually the low effort kind that earn nothing.

Step 6: What should I stay away from?

Stay away from anything that games votes or repeats itself. Reddit's spam policy names mass posting repetitive content, so the same comment pasted into several threads is out. The same policy names reposting old content to gain karma fast. Reddit's rules call coordinated voting vote manipulation, which covers subreddits and groups where people upvote each other, and buying upvotes from a service. If you have more than one account, Reddit says not to use them to vote on the same posts or comments.

Leave links out of your comments until the account has karma and a few weeks of ordinary history. Reddit's reputation filter lets moderators filter what accounts with no history post, and on our own accounts a link is what most often gets a comment removed. That last part is our own habit from running accounts and isn't in Reddit's rules.

What goes wrong: an account that leans on any of these can lose far more than the karma it gained. Reddit says that if your comments stop showing up for other people, the account may have been flagged for spam.

How do I know if my comments are being seen?

Log out, or open a private window, and look at your profile and your latest comment. If your profile reads as not found while you see everything as normal, your account has been hidden. We have seen this on our own accounts: an account looked fine to itself while everyone else saw a profile that wasn't there. A free shadowban checker shows whether other people can see an account, so you don't have to log out each time.

If you are hidden, Reddit's Help Center article on accounts flagged for spam or inauthentic activity says what to do next. Follow it before you comment again, because other people can't vote on comments they can't see.

How long does it take?

Reddit publishes no number, and we won't make one up. One comment can earn almost nothing and the next can take off. With a few comments a day, plan on weeks rather than days. For many communities the limit that matters is account age, which only time moves, so there is no point in rushing the karma side.

From our own work, a steady pace has been safe. One post a day from an aged account has not got any of our accounts hidden. We'd keep comments to the same steady pace: a few good ones every day, never a lot in one go.

Discuss it on Reddit, in r/Subgrow

More from the blog