How to create a subreddit for a brand: the two-minute form, and what broke for us after it

Creating a subreddit takes about two minutes. On reddit.com you click Create Community in the left sidebar, give it a name and a description, pick up to three topics, choose public, restricted or private, and confirm. In the app the same form sits behind the menu icon, under Start a Community. Reddit's own walkthrough is here.

That part is easy. We open subreddits for brands as our job, and nearly everything that has cost us a week happened in the hour before the form or the month after it. So this post spends two paragraphs on the form and the rest on what broke.

What do you need before you create a subreddit?

An account Reddit already trusts, a name you can live with forever, and a second person. In that order.

Reddit's help pages on creating a community don't name a minimum account age or karma figure, and we'd be suspicious of any guide that quotes one. What we can say from doing it is that an account registered that same week is the wrong one to use. Use the account that has been commenting for months. If you have nothing like that, spend a few weeks earning comment karma in other communities first, because the account that creates the subreddit becomes its first moderator and the subreddit inherits its standing.

The name must be 3 to 21 characters, and Reddit says it "cannot be edited after the community is created", capitalization included. Type it slowly. r/Yourbrand and r/YourBrand are the same address but they will not look the same at the top of the page, and you only get one try.

Which settings matter on the create form?

Three of them, and you can ignore the rest until later.

The name comes first. Check that it isn't taken before you get attached to it. One brand we work with found its exact name already registered years ago by someone else, with no posts in it.

For the type, choose public. A restricted community lets everyone read but only approved people post, which sounds safe for a brand and mostly keeps customers from asking anything. Start public and moderate.

Pick the three topics honestly. Reddit uses them to decide who gets shown the community, and it says it may change them later based on what actually gets posted.

The 18+ toggle labels the whole community NSFW. Leave it off unless that is truly what you sell.

What should you do in the first hour?

Add a second moderator, write the rules, and post before you invite anyone.

The second moderator is the step people skip, and it is the one we now refuse to skip. Twice this fall an account that had just created a community got hidden by Reddit within days (the profile shows as not found to everyone else, while the account itself sees nothing wrong). When the hidden account was the only moderator, we tried to invite a healthy one. Reddit accepted the invite and never delivered it. The subreddit was stranded, live and ours on paper, with nobody able to moderate it. We ended up opening a second community under a different name. A second moderator added on day one, while the creator is still in good standing, makes that whole failure harmless.

Then the rules. Four or five short ones is plenty. Say what belongs, what doesn't, whether competitors may be discussed (say yes), and how to reach a human at the company. Clear subreddit rules also protect you later, when you have to remove something and want a reason that was written down beforehand.

Then content. Reddit's guidance on seeding a new community is to have enough posts on day one "that a visitor would have to scroll to see all of it". That matches what we see. An empty brand subreddit reads as abandoned, and a visitor who lands on one doesn't come back to check.

Can you delete or rename a subreddit later?

No to both. Reddit's help center is blunt about it. Once a community is created it can't be deleted, and if every moderator leaves, it stays visible and can be claimed by someone else through r/redditrequest (source).

For a brand that changes the calculation. A subreddit you create and then neglect doesn't disappear. It sits at reddit.com/r/yourname with your name on it, and after enough silence a stranger can ask Reddit for the keys. If you aren't going to post in it for the next year, you're better off not creating it yet.

What goes wrong after the subreddit exists?

Mostly pacing. The two mistakes we've made ourselves were both about doing too much too soon.

The first was posting a burst from a fresh account. Several posts in the first day from an account with no history looks like spam, and it is our best explanation for why those two accounts got hidden. Reddit doesn't tell you the reason. One post a day from an aged account has not caused us that problem.

The second was creating communities too quickly. On the third subreddit one of our accounts opened in a single day, Reddit refused and told it to wait 15 hours. So if you're setting up a main community plus a support one plus a regional one, spread them over a week.

And check from the outside. An account that has been shadowbanned looks perfectly normal to itself. Log out, or use a different account, and look at the creator's profile and the subreddit's front page. If either says not found, stop posting and sort that out first.

Is it worth having your own subreddit at all?

For most software and consumer brands, yes, on one condition. Someone has to post in it every week for a long time.

The reason to bother is search. A thread in a community you moderate can rank on Google for the question it answers, the same way threads in any other subreddit do. In other people's communities you're a guest and your post can be removed for mentioning what you sell. In your own subreddit, answering questions about your product is the whole point of the place.

What it won't do is grow on its own. Nobody stumbles into a new subreddit. People arrive from a search result or a link, read one thread, and decide in a few seconds whether anyone is home. So the honest version of "how to create a subreddit" is that the creating is two minutes and the rest is a posting schedule. Have you got one?

Discuss it on Reddit, in r/Subgrow

More from the blog