How to choose an AI search optimization agency: what to ask before you sign
Pick an AI search optimization agency the way you would pick any SEO firm, then add three checks that are specific to AI answers: what exactly they will change, where outside mentions of your brand will come from, and how they will prove a result you can check without them. If an agency cannot answer those plainly before you sign, keep looking. The steps below go in the order you will meet them, with what tends to go wrong at each one.
What are you actually buying?
You are buying a better chance that AI answers (Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode, ChatGPT search, Perplexity and the rest) name your brand or link to your pages when a buyer asks about your category. Write down which engines matter to you and five to ten questions your buyers really ask before you talk to anyone.
What goes wrong here is letting the agency define the target for you. If they pick the prompts, they can pick ones you already win. Bring your own list, taken from sales calls and support tickets, and keep it.
It helps to know what Google itself says. Google's Search Central page "AI features and your website" says there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode and no special optimizations necessary. It says a page has to be indexed and eligible to show in Search with a snippet, and that you do not need new machine readable files, AI text files or special structured data. So an agency whose pitch rests on a secret file format or a markup trick for Google's AI features is selling something Google says you do not need.
Is your site even reachable by the AI engines?
Check this yourself before the first call, because it is one file and tells you how much of the pitch is real work. OpenAI's page "Overview of OpenAI Crawlers" says OAI-SearchBot is the crawler that surfaces websites in ChatGPT's search features, and that sites opted out of it will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers. The same page says GPTBot is the separate crawler for training, and the two are controlled independently in robots.txt.
Open your robots.txt and look for those two names. A site that blocks OAI-SearchBot by accident has a problem no agency content will fix. If the agency finds it, good; if they do not mention crawler access at all in their audit, that tells you how deep the audit went.
What will they change, and will they tell you?
Ask for a written list of every change they plan to make on your site and off it, with the reason for each. Google's page "Do you need an SEO?" suggests asking exactly this: whether they will share all the changes they make and the reasoning behind their recommendations. It also says to be careful if a company is secretive or will not clearly explain what it intends to do.
The usual failure is a monthly report full of activity words ("optimized", "seeded", "amplified") with no list of URLs. Ask for links. Every page they edit, every article they place, every comment they post should have an address you can open.
Where will the outside mentions come from?
If the plan includes getting your brand discussed on other sites, ask which ones, which accounts will post, who owns those accounts, and whether the posts say who they come from. Reddit comes up often in these plans because AI answers do cite it; the tracking described further down measured reddit.com as a share of ChatGPT Search citations.
Reddit's own rules set the line. Rule 2 asks people to participate authentically in communities where they have a personal interest and not to spam or engage in content manipulation. Rule 5 says not to intentionally mislead others or impersonate an individual or entity in a deceptive manner. In the US, the Federal Trade Commission's final rule on fake reviews, announced on 14 August 2024, bans reviews from people who do not exist, insider reviews that hide the writer's connection to the business, and buying fake indicators of social media influence such as bot followers or views.
So the red flags are a network of "real user" accounts praising you without disclosure, bought votes, or a promise of dozens of placements a week. The safer shapes are content your brand openly puts its name to, such as your own subreddit, and plainly written comments in threads that rank on Google, posted by accounts with a real history and a stated connection where one exists.
From our own work running subreddits for brands, Reddit's own systems are strict even with honest accounts. Twice this autumn an account that had just created a community was hidden by Reddit within days: everyone else saw its profile as not found, while the account itself saw nothing wrong. Reddit also refused the third community one account tried to create in a single day and told it to wait 15 hours. Pacing matters; one post a day from an aged account has not got an account hidden for us. Ask the agency what it does when an account is hidden, and how it would even notice; a shadowban check run on each posting account every week is a reasonable minimum.
Google's page "Do you need an SEO?" also says you are responsible for the actions of any company you hire, and deceptive content created on your behalf can get your site removed from Google's index.
How will they measure it, and can you check it without them?
Agree on two kinds of evidence before you sign: traffic you can see in your own tools, and a repeatable check of the AI answers themselves.
For Google, the AI features page says traffic from sites shown in AI features is counted in Search Console's Performance report under the Web search type. So it is mixed into your normal search numbers. An agency that claims to report "AI Overview clicks" from Search Console as a separate line should explain where that number comes from.
For ChatGPT, Perplexity and the others, measurement is done by tracking tools that run prompts and record which sources come back. Treat those numbers with care. A Relevant Audience article from August 2026, summarizing Promptwatch's tracking as reported by Search Engine Journal, describes reddit.com falling from 3.83% of ChatGPT Search citations between 18 July and 7 August to 0.52% between 14 and 17 August. The same article says Promptwatch called the size of the drop provisional and could not yet rule out a data collection problem on its own end. If the tracking vendors themselves warn that their data can move for reasons they cannot explain, treat a monthly chart from an agency as one reading among several.
The practical fix is to keep your own record. Take the question list from the first step, run each one in each engine on the day you sign, save screenshots, and repeat monthly. You can also check whether a specific page is among the threads ChatGPT cites with a free tool, but your own dated screenshots are what you will trust when a contract renewal comes up.
What timeline and guarantees are believable?
A believable answer is a range with conditions. Google's "Do you need an SEO?" page says no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google, and that if someone guarantees first place you should find someone else.
On timing, what we see is that Google can show a new Reddit post within hours, while AI answers take a few weeks to pick something up. An agency that promises AI citations in the first week, or that cannot say what should change by month two, is guessing.
What should the contract say?
Put the earlier answers in writing. The contract should name the engines and the prompt list you agreed on, require a monthly list of every URL they created or changed, say who owns any accounts, subreddits or content made for you and what happens to them if you leave, and allow you to stop the work within a month. Google's page also suggests asking how long they have been in business and for examples of past work; ask for examples you can open yourself, with the dates the work happened.
If the agency resists any of this, that is your answer. Choosing well comes down to the same habit at every step: ask for something you can check, then check it.
Discuss it on Reddit, in r/Subgrow