How we rank Reddit marketing agencies
The score measures how much of what an agency says about itself can be checked in public. It doesn't measure taste or talent, and nobody can pay to change it.
The score
A trust score out of 100, from five parts and one deduction:
| Part | Points | How it's earned |
|---|---|---|
| Named people | 20 | A founder or owner named on a public page, with a profile: 20. One named only by someone else: 14. People named but no founder: 8. Nobody named: 0, and the profile says "No founder publicly listed". |
| Time in business | 15 | Ten years or more: 15. Six to nine: 12. Three to five: 8. One or two: 4. Under a year, or no founding year published: 0. |
| Independent reviews | 25 | Reviews on sites the agency doesn't control, such as Clutch, G2, Trustpilot, Google or Upwork. Each site counts its rating times its volume, with 50 reviews counting in full. The best site counts whole and the others a quarter each. Testimonials on the agency's own site don't count. |
| Published results | 20 | Clients it names: 1 each, up to 6. Case studies that name the client: 2 each, up to 8. Case studies that link the actual Reddit posts or threads, so anyone can check them: 3 each, up to 6. |
| Openness | 10 | Prices published: 4. Location stated on its own site: 3. A public contact address: 3. |
| Documented problems | −25 | Each complaint documented on a public page: −5, up to −15. A documented ban or removal of its Reddit work: −10. |
75 and up is Well documented, 55 to 74 is Documented, 35 to 54 is Partly documented, and under 35 is Little public evidence. A low score says the evidence isn't public. It doesn't say the work is bad.
Some facts appear on a profile without moving the score. Each profile shows, from the agency's own pages, whether it grows a subreddit your brand owns, runs Reddit Ads, posts comments from accounts not presented as your brand, uses aged or warmed-up accounts, and buys or sells upvotes. Each answer is yes, no or not stated, with its source. They describe how an agency works, not whether you can hold it to account, so you can weigh them yourself.
Where evidence comes from
We use the agency's own site, its public company profiles, review sites, directories such as Clutch and DesignRush, press, and public discussion. Agencies come from those directories, from published “best Reddit agency” lists, and from search in many countries. An agency is listed if it sells Reddit work as a service: ads, posts, comments, community management or Reddit SEO. Generalists that only tick a Reddit box in a directory, with nothing about Reddit on their own site, are left out.
People are listed by name, role and public profile, with photos only where the person or their company published one. Each links to the page that shows it. Each agency's short description is written only from these same researched facts, and its logo and homepage picture are taken from its own website on the date shown.
How scores are checked
After scoring, a second reviewer tries to knock down every score and every flag. Is the founder really named on that page? Are the reviews on that platform about this agency? Is the complaint about this company, and is it documented? Only what survives the second pass is published. A flag that can't be backed by a link is removed.
Categories and awards
Every agency is ranked within its country and region, within each service it sells (Reddit Ads, organic posts and comments, Reddit SEO and AI search, community management, AMAs, reputation), within the industries it serves, and among Reddit specialists. In each category the top three by score are nominated, and the first is the winner. Five more awards cut across categories: most independently reviewed, longest in business, best documented results, clearest pricing (prices on the agency's own site), and rising specialist. An agency scoring under 35 isn't nominated.
Corrections
The directory is re-researched and re-scored on the same rules. If something about your agency is wrong or out of date, send the page that shows the correct fact to hello@subgrow.ai. Facts change the score; requests without a source don't.
Published by Subgrow, which sells Reddit marketing itself, so Subgrow is not ranked here. No agency paid to be listed or ranked. Every score comes from public evidence, with the source linked, under the same rules for everyone. Agencies that see something wrong can write to hello@subgrow.ai.