Check this rating ·
pfSense: #4 among firewalls on Reddit
Every Reddit post and comment behind pfSense's rank and sentiment, with a link to each one, so you can count them yourself.
The rank
pfSense is named in 129 posts and comments across 24 of the 49 threads we counted: 6.4% of all brand mentions, rank #4 of 134 products named.
Sentiment
- Positive 70
- Neutral 40
- Negative 19
An AI model read each post and comment once and labelled how it treats pfSense, with a one-line reason. Net sentiment is the positive share minus the negative share of the labelled mentions. A model can misread sarcasm or a comparison, so each label below links to the comment it was given for.
Every mention
Homelab Firewalls - What are you using?
- NegativeThe post, May 11, 2026Dislikes online-only installer and required Netgate account.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026Running without issues.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026Solid over four years, though setup took extra time.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026Ran it for over five years.
- NeutralComment, May 11, 2026Used before but lacked Palo Alto's feature set.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026Runs without issues and prefers its UI.
- NeutralComment, May 11, 2026Used for many years professionally; no view expressed.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026No issues while still using pfSense.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026Works reliably over about ten years.
- NeutralComment, May 11, 2026Chosen again after OPNsense problems; no direct praise.
- NeutralComment, May 11, 2026Still kept only due to laziness.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026Long-time user, would not change, prefers its UI.
- NeutralComment, May 11, 2026Considered as a future option; no view yet.
- NeutralComment, May 11, 2026Explicitly not using it; no criticism given.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026Likes it, stable for years, minor update concern.
- NegativeComment, May 11, 2026Warns against it over ethics and software quality.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026Says pfSense forever.
- NeutralComment, May 11, 2026Mentioned only as a past firewall before EdgeRouter.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026Considering returning for stability.
- PositiveComment, May 11, 2026Long-term router use.
- PositiveComment, May 12, 2026Runs pfSense with patches; warns against old software.
What's the best free firewall option?
- NegativeThe post, May 16, 2025Not fully convinced by current pfSense setup.
- NeutralComment, May 16, 2025Used as comparison point only.
- PositiveComment, May 16, 2025Listed among the only dedicated firewall options.
- PositiveComment, May 16, 2025Enterprise focus, stability, and strong vendor support.
- NeutralComment, May 16, 2025Seen as reliable though release testing questioned.
- PositiveComment, May 16, 2025Long-term use and preferred interface.
- PositiveComment, May 16, 2025Ten years of solid use across multiple hardware platforms.
- PositiveComment, May 16, 2025Listed among only free tried-and-tested options.
- NegativeComment, May 16, 2025Accused of not being open-source.
- PositiveComment, May 16, 2025Long-term use and happiness reported.
- NeutralComment, May 16, 2025Good pure firewall but limited NGFW features.
- NegativeComment, May 16, 2025Fears a similar rugpull; chose OPNsense instead.
- PositiveComment, May 16, 2025Built on FreeBSD's strong firewall options.
- NegativeComment, May 16, 2025Free offer pulled back, forcing reinstalls and restores.
- NegativeComment, May 16, 2025Third-party extensions cause headaches.
- NeutralComment, May 16, 2025Closed source and American, stated without clear criticism.
- PositiveComment, May 17, 2025Calls it great and previously used it.
- PositiveComment, May 17, 2025Settled on it; stable, smooth upgrades, and reliable.
- PositiveComment, May 17, 2025Called this product amazing.
- NeutralComment, May 21, 2025Recommends specific free and paid firewall solutions.
What firewalls does your shop use and what are the pros and cons?
- PositiveComment, February 27, 2026Called one of the best; skill need isn't a con.
- NegativeComment, February 27, 2026Management at scale described as difficult.
- NeutralComment, February 27, 2026Good for homelab, rough as main firewall; admits no experience.
- PositiveComment, February 27, 2026Called awesome and among best used.
- PositiveComment, February 27, 2026Solid, reliable, and feature-rich.
- NegativeComment, February 27, 2026Lacked bulk manage, report, patch, and update.
- NegativeComment, February 27, 2026Most issues among prior firewalls.
- NegativeComment, February 27, 2026Weak advanced features but still used for basic NAT.
- PositiveComment, February 27, 2026Likes it despite NGFW and central-management gaps.
- PositiveComment, March 3, 2026Recommended alongside OPNsense; avoids subscription costs.
What are the best free or cheap firewalls or firewall VMs or SIEMs I can use at home to protect my internet at home, like Pfsense, Sophia, Fortinet, Palo Alto, etc.?
- NeutralThe post, September 21, 2025Seeking guidance and recommendations for home security tools.
- PositiveComment, September 21, 2025Strongly recommends open source options for community and familiarity.
- PositiveComment, September 21, 2025Recommended in security stack.
- NeutralComment, September 21, 2025Used as comparison baseline only.
- NeutralComment, September 21, 2025Asking if security performance matches a competitor.
- PositiveComment, September 21, 2025Claims sophisticated security features protect better.
- NeutralComment, September 21, 2025Suggest personal skill level affects comparison results.
- NeutralComment, September 22, 2025Asking for judgment on free product quality.
- PositiveComment, April 18, 2026Explicitly ranks Sophos highest among these products.
- PositiveComment, April 18, 2026The author provides a preference ranking of security solutions.
Firewall Vendor of Choice?
- PositiveThe post, January 29, 2025Lists it as a reasonable alternative.
- PositiveComment, January 29, 2025Go-to choice for small office setups.
- NeutralComment, January 29, 2025Deployed with Suricata and log ingestion; no evaluation.
- NeutralComment, January 29, 2025Says it has issues but improves with releases.
- PositiveComment, January 29, 2025Recommends pfSense and cites replacing Sophos after a VPN failure.
- PositiveComment, January 29, 2025Good option for smaller clients.
- PositiveComment, January 30, 2025Liked for super small offices.
- NeutralComment, January 30, 2025Flashed to an SSD; no praise or complaint.
- PositiveComment, January 30, 2025Works well and is widely deployed.
- NeutralComment, January 30, 2025Customizable but has a learning curve.
Is an at home firewall worth it?
- NeutralComment, January 8, 2026Named as example with a free home-user tier.
- NeutralComment, January 8, 2026Asked about as possible option.
- PositiveComment, January 8, 2026Suggests pfSense as an alternative.
- PositiveComment, January 8, 2026Suggested alternative with free updates.
- PositiveComment, January 8, 2026Used successfully before switching to OPNsense.
- PositiveComment, January 9, 2026Recommended firewall OS for mini PC.
- PositiveComment, January 9, 2026Recommended over SonicWall.
What would you recommend for new Firewall
- PositiveComment, January 29, 2026Recommended when budget is tight.
- PositiveComment, January 29, 2026Fits small operations easily; recommended.
- PositiveComment, January 29, 2026Recommends it as a cheap option.
- NeutralComment, January 29, 2026Mentioned as possible but with an unspecified caveat.
- PositiveComment, January 30, 2026Great solution on Protectli hardware.
- NegativeComment, January 30, 2026OPNsense chosen instead, implying less satisfaction.
Best Free Network Firewall for non-commercial use
- NegativeThe post, September 3, 2025Finds pfSense clunky with plugins and difficult decryption.
- NegativeComment, September 3, 2025Shifted away after years; tired of managing it.
- PositiveComment, September 3, 2025Nice and powerful after learning the interface.
- NeutralComment, September 4, 2025Old and hard for ACLs but still used.
- PositiveComment, September 4, 2025Rough but teaches core networking parts.
- PositiveComment, September 7, 2025Recommended as the free firewall.
What firewall do you have at home?
- NeutralComment, January 25, 2025Named as an option only.
- NeutralComment, January 25, 2025Named as firewall in use, no evaluation.
- PositiveComment, January 25, 2025Preferred alternative to current firewall.
- NeutralComment, January 25, 2025Listed as alternative.
- NeutralComment, January 26, 2025Described as running on a Dell micro.
- NeutralComment, January 26, 2025Mentions moving back to pfSense, with no clear evaluation.
New Firewall Recommendations (10 year service life)
- PositiveComment, October 19, 2026Suggests looking at it and notes fewer security holes.
- PositiveComment, October 19, 2026Feels more comfortable and has helpful open-source support.
- NegativeComment, October 19, 2026Owns little security software; disclosures mostly UI-only
- NegativeComment, October 19, 2026Criticizes vendor ethics and code quality.
- PositiveComment, October 20, 2026Capable and reliable CARP failover; praised for HA
Hi guys, what is your opinion and experience of a good firewall brand (or an explicit model) for small to medium sized companies (60+ people)?
- PositiveComment, February 11, 2025Suggested firewall option.
- NegativeComment, February 11, 2025Regrets deploying before issues arose.
- PositiveComment, February 11, 2025Used as a working replacement.
- PositiveComment, February 11, 2025Only uses pfSense; sees it as easy.
- PositiveComment, February 11, 2025Uses pfSense; notes forced registration but hardware is good.
Best home firewall?
- PositiveComment, December 22, 2024Suggested alongside OPNsense.
- NeutralComment, December 22, 2024Mentioned only for lacking Raspberry Pi support.
- NeutralComment, December 22, 2024Listed as one remaining home firewall option.
- NegativeComment, December 22, 2024Community edition support is weak and licensing feels unreliable.
- NeutralComment, December 22, 2024Longtime use praised, but current direction worries.
Best firewall for homelab
- PositiveComment, September 17, 2025Chosen as the firewall in recommended build.
- PositiveComment, September 17, 2025Easy subnet, NAT, and rule management; recommended.
- PositiveComment, September 18, 2025Used successfully for years.
Network Engineers, What firewall would you pick if it is up to you?
- PositiveComment, May 28, 2025Flexible and fast but needs skills.
- PositiveComment, May 29, 2025Calls pfSense a good network firewall.
- NeutralComment, May 29, 2025Only a naming clarification, with no product evaluation
Small Dr. Office - Firewall/Router Suggestions.
- PositiveComment, January 30, 2025Recommended as part of best cheap setup.
- NeutralComment, January 31, 2025Not bad but lacks support; supported cost rivals Sophos.
- PositiveComment, January 31, 2025Called reliable and easy to manage.
Firewall/Router Hardware & OS recommendations with best "futureproofing"
- PositiveComment, March 18, 2026Long use with quick fixes; fork noted.
Firewall is Paid walled now? WTF
- PositiveComment, January 27, 2026Used as advanced firewall instead of paid features.
NGFW Comparison - Cisco/Palo Alto/Fortinet/Checkpoint
- PositiveComment, December 25, 2025Great small-shop choice with low support cost.
What firewall would you recommend? Setting up firewall for a small 10-20 employee company, currently they are using Sophos firewall on the same server that they host all the other software?
- NeutralComment, October 25, 2025Mentioned as an option only for those who know it.
What’s the best firewall setup for a homelab in 2025?
- NeutralThe post, July 24, 2025Mentioned as a software option in a question.
Are Firewall Security Subscription Services Obsolete?
- NeutralComment, May 14, 2025Notes it now offers paid security services.
Which firewall vendor you think is most experience valuable today?
- NeutralComment, April 3, 2025Listed among other options without evaluation.
Best Home Firewall
- NegativeComment, August 15, 2025Had uncorrectable issues and community problems, so dumped it.
Free or open source family friendly firewall for home?
- PositiveComment, February 7, 2025Also calls it one of the best options.
How we count
For each category we search Google in the United States for the same ten buyer questions, each as written and again with "reddit" added. People also ask about one product by name, so each of the 15 products named in the most threads is searched as well: "site:reddit.com" with its website, or with its name when we have no website. We keep the Reddit threads Google shows. A thread whose title is about a different kind of product, or about no product at all, is left out, by the same check in every category. We read every remaining thread and count each post or comment that names a brand as one mention for that brand, whether it praises the product, compares it or complains about it.
A brand's rank is its number of mentions; share of mentions is that number out of all brand mentions in the category. Ties go to the brand named in more threads. Only posts and comments from the last 24 months count, a brand must be named in at least 3 separate threads to be ranked, and a category is published once it has 25 threads and 100 mentions. The count is redone every 30 days.
No brand list decides who can appear, and no brand is placed, moved or removed by hand. An AI model reads each thread and lists the products it names; we keep a mention only when the name is literally written in that post or comment. A second pass joins spellings of one product, so "VS Code" and "Visual Studio Code" are one row, and counts a tool that carries a product's name with that product, so "Claude Code" counts as Claude, "Gemini CLI" as Gemini and "Codex" as ChatGPT. It can still misread a name that is also an ordinary word.
Sentiment is read from the same posts and comments. A second AI model reads each one once and says whether it is positive, neutral or negative about each product it names, with a one-line reason: a comment that left one product for another counts against the first and for the second. A brand's net sentiment is its share of positive mentions minus its share of negative ones, from -100 to +100; it is shown once at least 10 of its mentions are labelled. Sentiment never changes a brand's rank. Every label can be checked: each brand's "Check" page lists every mention behind its rank, linked to the post or comment on Reddit, with the label and the reason.
Subgrow sells Reddit marketing, and some brands listed here may be our customers; they are counted like any other. Posts and comments written from accounts we run, or as work we arranged, are identified and left out of every number, and a thread we started is left out whole. No Reddit usernames are shown or stored with these counts.