Check this rating ·

Hill's: #3 among cat foods on Reddit

Every Reddit post and comment behind Hill's's rank and sentiment, with a link to each one, so you can count them yourself.

The rank

Hill's is named in 502 posts and comments across 100 of the 176 threads we counted: 8.5% of all brand mentions, rank #3 of 249 products named.

Back to the ranking: Cat food

Sentiment

Not read yet
  • Positive 0
  • Neutral 0
  • Negative 0
  • Not labelled 502

An AI model read each post and comment once and labelled how it treats Hill's, with a one-line reason. Net sentiment is the positive share minus the negative share of the labelled mentions, shown once 10 are labelled. A model can misread sarcasm or a comparison, so each label below links to the comment it was given for.

Every mention

  1. is there something going on with hill’s science cat food?

    r/CatAdviceJan 202660 mentions

  2. Which Hills food are you feeding your indoor cats?

    r/catfoodJan 202633 mentions

  3. everyone on here is telling me to stop feeding purina one. what brands should i switch over to?

    r/catfoodAug 202514 mentions

  4. What is the best brand of cat food?

    r/yesmycatFeb 202514 mentions

  5. Is Royal Canin as good as they say?

    r/catfoodSep 202613 mentions

  6. Confusion with Royal Canin cat food

    r/catfoodFeb 202512 mentions

  7. Orijen cat food has made all 4 of our cats extremely sick in the last month. We have bought this same food for 4 years, but now the quality has been lost & our cats all have bloody diarrhea, puking and runny eyes.

    r/catfoodJan 202511 mentions

  8. Tiki Cat is garbage now

    r/catfoodMay 202610 mentions

  9. Is Hills Science diet dry food safe? (cats)

    r/PetsFeb 202510 mentions

  10. Expensive food vs. Cheap food

    r/catfoodNov 20269 mentions

  11. Is orijen a good cat food?

    r/catfoodJul 20269 mentions

  12. is high end food really worth the extra money?

    r/catfoodJun 20269 mentions

  13. Long time cat owners: what cat food do you recommend?

    r/catfoodJun 20269 mentions

  14. Best cat food brands

    r/catfoodMay 20269 mentions

  15. What are we feeding are cats now that tiki cat sucks?

    r/catfoodOct 20259 mentions

  16. Is Royal Canin cat food good or bad

    r/PetsMar 20259 mentions

  17. Best Cat Food Brands?

    r/CatAdviceOct 20268 mentions

  18. Hill's Prescription Diet z/d cat food experience

    r/catfoodAug 20268 mentions

  19. Is Royal Canin good?

    r/catfoodJul 20268 mentions

  20. Thoughts on Orijen?

    r/catfoodAug 20258 mentions

  21. Trying to find safe cat food — Iams or Science Diet? 🐱

    r/catfoodFeb 20267 mentions

  22. is purina a good brand?

    r/catfoodNov 20257 mentions

  23. I need new cat food recommendations ASAP. I’ve been feeding my cat Meow Mix. I’ve just found out that the brand is actually horrible?

    r/catfoodDec 20247 mentions

  24. Honestly what is happening with fancy feast???

    r/catfoodMar 20266 mentions

  25. [deleted by user]

    r/catfoodJan 20266 mentions

  26. Budget AND cat-friendly dry food?

    r/catfoodJan 20266 mentions

  27. Advice about hills cat food

    r/catfoodJan 20266 mentions

  28. Any opinions on Nulo?

    r/catfoodSep 20256 mentions

  29. Adult cat food recommendations

    r/catfoodJan 20256 mentions

  30. is fancy feast rly the mcdonald’s of cat food? what other kitten food brands do yall recommend?

    r/CatAdviceOct 20265 mentions

  31. Is Tiki Cat good?

    r/CatAdviceOct 20265 mentions

  32. Is Nulo actually that bad?

    r/catfoodSep 20265 mentions

  33. I analyzed 80+ Reddit threads to find the 40 most recommended cat foods (with sentiment analysis)

    r/catfoodOct 20255 mentions

  34. Looking to try weruva but feeling a bit overwhelmed with the options

    r/catfoodMay 20255 mentions

  35. The people I work with said that Meow Mix is horrible to feed your cats....

    r/catfoodFeb 20255 mentions

  36. So is Purina pro plan good or overpriced and mediocre?

    r/catfoodJul 20245 mentions

  37. How good is Hill's Science Diet?

    r/CatAdviceAug 20215 mentions

  38. Sheba wet food switch

    r/catfoodApr 20264 mentions

  39. Wellness Cat Food

    r/catfoodMar 20264 mentions

  40. Vet called fancy feast McDonald's

    r/CatAdviceFeb 20264 mentions

  41. A little rant about royal canin

    r/CatAdviceJan 20264 mentions

  42. Is fancy feast a good brand? Specifically thinking about the wet food. It’s affordable so I am wondering if there is any downsides. Is it better or worse than hills and science diet?

    r/CatAdviceNov 20254 mentions

  43. what is everyone using for wet cat food?

    r/CatAdviceAug 20254 mentions

  44. Wet cat food

    r/CatAdviceJul 20254 mentions

  45. Blue Buffalo

    r/catfoodApr 20254 mentions

  46. IAMS CAT FOOD

    r/catfoodOct 20263 mentions

  47. Friskies for male cat

    r/CatAdviceJul 20263 mentions

  48. Weruva Dry Food

    r/catfoodMay 20263 mentions

  49. Best Affordable Cat Food?

    r/CatAdviceMay 20253 mentions

  50. Reviews on Blue Buffalo Tastefuls?

    r/catfoodApr 20253 mentions

  51. What do you think of Fancy Feast?

    r/CatAdviceFeb 20253 mentions

  52. Does anyone have any cats that have lived long on friskies/fancy?

    r/CatAdviceFeb 20253 mentions

  53. should I switch away from orijen?

    r/catfoodJan 20253 mentions

  54. Can someone explain why friskies is bad for cats? And what I should switch too if she’s picky?

    r/CatAdviceJan 20253 mentions

  55. Thoughts on Hill's?

    r/catfoodJul 20243 mentions

  56. Best quality food

    r/CatAdviceJan 20243 mentions

  57. Fancy Feast: Good or Bad?

    r/CatAdviceAug 20233 mentions

  58. Hello! i am wondering if IAMS is a good cat food or not. i’m seeing so much mixed answers everywhere i look and resorted to here. i’ve been sticking with it because it’s the food i can get easily as i don’t travel too much. :)

    r/catfoodFeb 20233 mentions

  59. Worried over new studies-Misled about Iams. Safest foods?

    r/catfoodOct 20262 mentions

  60. THOUGHTS ON BLUE BUFFALO?WHAT DRY FOOD DO YOU USE??

    r/catsJun 20262 mentions

  61. What is the best of the best cat food?

    r/CatAdviceMar 20262 mentions

  62. Is fancy feast an ok brand?

    r/CatAdviceJan 20262 mentions

  63. Is Blue Buffalo okay for cats?

    r/catfoodSep 20252 mentions

  64. I've been feeding my cat Iams brand dry food just to find out its bad for him.

    r/catfoodSep 20252 mentions

  65. Blue Buffalo Basics single protein cat food is a LIFESAVER!

    r/CatAdviceAug 20252 mentions

  66. please read this if you feed ur cats the ‘Wellness’ brand

    r/catfoodJul 20252 mentions

  67. Blue Buffalo Wilderness

    r/catfoodMay 20252 mentions

  68. What are the best brands / what food to buy for cat as first time owner

    r/catfoodMar 20252 mentions

  69. Warning about Tiki Cat

    r/catfoodMar 20252 mentions

  70. Please do not feed orijean cat food or treats! STAY AWAY !!!!

    r/catfoodJan 20252 mentions

  71. Cat wet food suggestions

    r/catfoodDec 20242 mentions

  72. What do you think about Orijen?

    r/catfoodAug 20242 mentions

  73. Why or why not Nulo?

    r/catfoodAug 20242 mentions

  74. Likely a beaten to death question, but better brands than Meow Mix?

    r/CatAdviceFeb 20242 mentions

  75. Good quality, budget friendly dry cat food?

    r/catfoodJan 20242 mentions

  76. Is expensive cat food worth it?

    r/CatAdviceAug 20232 mentions

  77. I buy Purina One for my cats, bills are going sky high, how bad are the cheaper alternatives?

    r/CatAdviceMar 20232 mentions

  78. Vet said that Tiki Cat canned wet food was similar to Whiskas and Fancy Feast aka "the McDonald's of cat food." Anyone know why this might be?

    r/CatAdviceMay 20212 mentions

  79. Did Iams healthy adult cat food change??

    r/catfoodSep 20261 mention

  80. Is Weruva one of the more "ethical" cat food brands?

    r/catfoodSep 20261 mention

  81. What dry food is best for cats? Orijen chicken alternatives

    r/catfoodAug 20261 mention

  82. Best affordable cat food?

    r/catfoodJun 20261 mention

  83. Is Sheba bad food?

    r/CatsUKJun 20261 mention

  84. I had to stop giving my cats Weruva

    r/catfoodMay 20261 mention

  85. Wellness vs Fancy Feast wet food. Worth switching for cost reasons?

    r/CatownerhacksMar 20261 mention

  86. Looking for affordable, high-quality wet food recommendations for my 7-year-old cat

    r/catfoodFeb 20261 mention

  87. Dry cat food brands

    r/catfoodDec 20251 mention

  88. What are your thoughts on Orijins cat food + suggestions for transitioning to adult food?

    r/CatAdviceJun 20251 mention

  89. What ingredients are in royal canin food?

    r/catfoodJan 20251 mention

  90. Thoughts on Sheba cat food?

    r/catfoodDec 20241 mention

  91. Is friskies wet food that bad for cats?

    r/CatAdviceNov 20241 mention

  92. Is wellness wet cat food good for cats? Looking to switch from fancy feast.

    r/catfoodNov 20241 mention

  93. What's everyone's opinion on Weruva wet food?

    r/catfoodOct 20241 mention

  94. Google is useless. anyone know the best DRY cat food?

    r/catfoodOct 20241 mention

  95. Better cat food/is fancy feast bad?

    r/CatAdviceOct 20241 mention

  96. Wellness or WSAVA compliant brands?

    r/catfoodAug 20241 mention

  97. Is Purina safe for cats?

    r/CatAdviceJan 20241 mention

  98. Best cat food recommendations

    r/CatAdviceMay 20231 mention

  99. How bad is a Churu a day if your cat's diet is relatively healthy the rest of the day?

    r/CatAdviceJan 20231 mention

  100. My Cat Food Resources (Guides, Spreadsheets, Info)

    r/catfoodAug 20221 mention

How we count

For each category we search Google in the United States for the same ten buyer questions, each as written and again with "reddit" added. People also ask about one product by name, so each of the 15 products named in the most threads is searched as well: "site:reddit.com" with its website, or with its name when we have no website. We keep the Reddit threads Google shows. A thread whose title is about a different kind of product, or about no product at all, is left out, by the same check in every category. We read every remaining thread and count each post or comment that names a brand as one mention for that brand, whether it praises the product, compares it or complains about it.

A brand's rank is its number of mentions; share of mentions is that number out of all brand mentions in the category. Ties go to the brand named in more threads. Only posts and comments from the last 24 months count, a brand must be named in at least 3 separate threads to be ranked, and a category is published once it has 25 threads and 100 mentions. The count is redone every 30 days.

No brand list decides who can appear, and no brand is placed, moved or removed by hand. An AI model reads each thread and lists the products it names; we keep a mention only when the name is literally written in that post or comment. A second pass joins spellings of one product, so "VS Code" and "Visual Studio Code" are one row, and counts a tool that carries a product's name with that product, so "Claude Code" counts as Claude, "Gemini CLI" as Gemini and "Codex" as ChatGPT. It can still misread a name that is also an ordinary word.

Sentiment is read from the same posts and comments. A second AI model reads each one once and says whether it is positive, neutral or negative about each product it names, with a one-line reason: a comment that left one product for another counts against the first and for the second. A brand's net sentiment is its share of positive mentions minus its share of negative ones, from -100 to +100; it is shown once at least 10 of its mentions are labelled. Sentiment never changes a brand's rank. Every label can be checked: each brand's "Check" page lists every mention behind its rank, linked to the post or comment on Reddit, with the label and the reason.

Subgrow sells Reddit marketing, and some brands listed here may be our customers; they are counted like any other. Posts and comments written from accounts we run, or as work we arranged, are identified and left out of every number, and a thread we started is left out whole. No Reddit usernames are shown or stored with these counts.